A Comparative Legal Analysis of Competition Law Protections for MSMEs in ASEAN Member States

R. Benny Riyanto; Sucihatiningsih Dian Wisika Prajanti; Dina Silvia Puteri

doi:10.15294/ildisea.v4i2.36142

Authors

R. Benny Riyanto Faculty of Law, Universitas Negeri Semarang Author
Sucihatiningsih Dian Wisika Prajanti Faculty of Economics and Business, Universitas Negeri Semarang Author
Dina Silvia Puteri Faculty of Law, Universitas Negeri Semarang Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.15294/ildisea.v4i2.36142

Keywords:

MSMEs, Business Competition Law, Digital Economy, ASEAN

Abstract

This research analyzes the adequacy of legal protection for Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) against trade monopoly practices within the rapidly evolving digital market landscape of the Industrial Revolution 4.0 era. Although Indonesia’s Law Number 5 of 1999 provides preventive safeguards—such as prohibitions on anti-competitive agreements under Articles 5–8—and repressive mechanisms through administrative and criminal sanctions under Articles 30–37, these provisions remain structurally limited in addressing digital-platform dominance and algorithm-driven market distortions. The normative gap between traditional competition law and contemporary digital market realities necessitates a reassessment of MSME protection. Employing a normative legal research design with a statute approach, conceptual approach, comparative approach, and law-and-policy analysis, this study evaluates whether Indonesia’s current framework sufficiently responds to digital-era challenges. Comparative examination of Malaysia, Singapore, and Thailand demonstrates more adaptive regulatory models that integrate digital market oversight into competition law—evident in Malaysia’s Competition Act 2010 and MyDIGITAL Blueprint, Singapore’s enforcement by the Competition and Consumer Commission (CCCS) over dominant online platforms, and Thailand’s Trade Competition Act 2017, aligned with Thailand 4.0. These jurisdictions illustrate a functional convergence toward platform regulation, data transparency, and digital market fairness. This research argues that Indonesia must harmonize its competition policy with digital transformation by adopting platform-specific rules, strengthening algorithmic accountability, and integrating MSME-focused digital market protections. By situating business competition law within the broader digital-economy governance discourse, the study contributes a socio-legal and policy-oriented framework for promoting equitable and sustainable market participation for MSMEs in ASEAN’s digitalized economy.

References

Afriana, A., A. M. Karsona, and S. A. Putri. 2020. “Partnership in the Perspective of Business Competition and Dispute Resolution.” ACTA DIURNAL Journal of Notarial Law 4 (1): 1–17, https://doi.org/10.23920/acta.v4i1.359.

Albab, S. U., E. Widayanto, and K. B. Sibarani. 2023. “Monitoring the Implementation of MSME and Large Business Partnerships: Comparison of Arrangements in Indonesia and Malaysia.” Journal of Business Competition 3 (1): 74–86.

Angayar Kanni Ramaiah. “Competition Law and Exemption Policy in Malaysia: When, Why and Why Not?” International Journal of Business, Economics and Law 8, no. 4 (2015): 80–89.

Apriani, D. 2019. “Review of Business Competition Law in Indonesia from the Perspective of Consumer Protection Law.” Legal Panorama Journal 4 (1): 19–30.

Apriani, D., and S. Syafrinaldi. 2022. “Norm Conflict Between Small Business Protection According to Indonesian Business Competition Law and Consumer Protection.” Journal of Indonesian Legal Development 4 (1): 14–33.

Apriani, N., and R. W. Said. 2022. “Legal Protection Efforts for the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSME) Industry in Indonesia.” Al Azhar Indonesian Journal Social Sciences Series 3 (1): 443234.

Artharini, N. F. 2023. “Protection for MSMEs Against Unfair Business Competition.” Dharmasisya: FHUI Law Masters Program Journal 2 (3): 27.

Azizee Aziz, Mathivannan Jaganathan, and Shamsul Huda Abd. Rani. Digital Entrepreneurship Adoption Among the Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises in Malaysia. Malaysia: Politeknik Tuanku Syed Sirajuddin and Universiti Utara Malaysia, 2022. ISBN 978-623-99591-4-2.

Bal, Hasan Çebi, and Çisil Erkan. "Industry 4.0 and competitiveness." Procedia computer science 158 (2019): 625-631.

Competition and Consumer Commission of Singapore. “Understanding Competition Act.” Accessed November 10, 2025. https://www.ccs.gov.sg/anti-competitive-practices/legislation-and-guidelines/understanding-competition-act/.

Economic Research Institute for ASEAN and East Asia et al. Study on MSMEs Participation in the Digital Economy in ASEAN: Nurturing ASEAN MSMEs to Embrace Digital Adoption. Bangkok: ERIA / Mitsubishi Research Institute / Spire Research & Consulting, 2018. https://connectivity.asean.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/ASEAN-MSME-Full-Report-Final.pdf.

Editama Joremia Sitepu, Putra Hasian Marbun, Doni Fernando Nainggolan, and Martono Anggusti. “Comparison of Indonesian and Malaysian Laws on Prohibition of Monopolistic Practices and Business Competition.” Golden Ratio of Data in Summary 5, no. 2 (2025): 211–222. https://goldenratio.id/index.php/grdis.

Fathari, Muhammad Reza, and Andi Rifky Maulana Efendy. “Harmonizing Regional Competition Laws and Policies: A Way Forward for ASEAN Economic Growth.” Indonesian Comparative Law Review 5, no. 2 (2025). http://dx.doi.org/10.18196/iclr.v5i2.17910.

Galasintu, Sareeya, and Chanakant Loveera. “The Comparative Study on Consumer Protection Laws in ASEAN.” Kasetsart University Journal 42, no. 4 (2021): 77–95.

Graham, Mark, and William H. Dutton, eds. Society and the internet: How networks of information and communication are changing our lives. Oxford University Press, 2019.

Hamidi, M. P., M. A. Fadli, and Y. W. Wilion. 2022. “Overview of the Green Economy in Business Competition Law in Indonesia.” Journal of Business Competition 2 (1): 5–19, https://doi.org/10.55869/kppu.v3i-.48.

Kartini, T. 2016. “The Impact of Business Competition Between Indomaret and Alfamart on Traditional Traders Viewed from a Business Competition Law Perspective.” Living Law Scientific Journal 8 (1).

Krause, David. “The Rise of Online Scams and Consumer Protections: A Comparative Analysis of the U.S. and Singapore.” SSRN, February 12, 2025. https://ssrn.com/abstract=5134496

Kurita, Makoto. Economic Law Reforms in the ASEAN Emerging Economies. Singapore: Springer, 2023.

Kurt, Resul. "Industry 4.0 in terms of industrial relations and its impacts on labour life." Procedia computer science 158 (2019): 590-601.

Matompo, O. S., and M. Nafri. 2020. “Industrial Revolution 4.0 in the Perspective of Business Competition Law in Indonesia.” Maleo Law Journal 4 (2): 126–136.

Nghia, Tang Van, Pham Thi, and Cam Anh. “Compliance with Competition Law: Related Issues for SMEs in ASEAN Countries.” Journal of Legal, Ethical & Regulatory Issues 25 (2022): 1–15. or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.5134496.

Prahmana, V. D., and D. Wiradiputra. 2022. “Predatory Pricing in E-Commerce According to a Business Competition Law Perspective.” JISIP (Journal of Social Sciences and Education) 6 (3), doi: https://doi.org/10.58258/jisip.v6i3.3277.

Retnowulan, Evi, and Anang Setiyawan. “Comparative Study on the Use of Legal Instruments in ASEAN Economic Community.” (2017).

Rodrigues, Thales Volpe, Vitor Hugo dos Santos Filho, Joseane Pontes, Luis Mauricio Martins de Resende, and Rui Tadashi Yoshino. "Goverment initiatives 4.0: a comparison between industrial innovation policies for industry 4.0." Revista Gestão e Desenvolvimento 18, no. 1 (2021): 119-147.

Rompegading, M. 2021. “Implementation of Business Competition Law during the Pandemic for MSMEs in Makassar City.” Journal of Business Competition 1 (1): 5–15.

Sari, D. P., and S. Ismawati. 2022. “Analysis of the Obligatory Provisions for Providing Business Space for MSME/IKM Business Actors Based on DKI Jakarta Regional Regulation No. 2 of 2018 concerning Markets from the Perspective of Business Competition Law Objectives.” Jakarta Research Journal 15 (2): 69–72, https://doi.org/10.37439/jurnaldrd.v15i2.67.

Schaper, Michael T., and Cassey Lee. Competition Law, Regulation and SMEs in the Asia-Pacific: Understanding the Challenges. Singapore: Springer, 2018.

Schwab, Klaus. The fourth industrial revolution. Crown Currency, 2017.

Stevanny, S., and N. L. V. W. S. Putri. 2023. “Controlling Monopoly Competition in Civil Law: Efforts to Protect Consumers and Small Entrepreneurs.” Mandub: Journal of Politics, Social, Law and Humanities 1 (3): 286–298, https://doi.org/10.59059/mandub.v1i3.439.

Sudiro, A., R. D. Fernandha, G. C. Mambo Jr., and R. M. A. H. S. 2023. “Socialization of Legal Aspects and Legal Protection of MSMEs in Indramayu Regency.” Serina Abdimas Journal 1 (1): 329–337, https://doi.org/10.24912/jsa.v1i1.24527.

Tektona, R. 2022. “Quo Vadis: Legal Certainty of Rules for Monopoly Practices and Unfair Business Competition in Law Number 11 of 2020 concerning Job Creation.” Journal of Business Competition 2 (1): 43–54, https://doi.org/10.55869/kppu.v3i-.51.

Thailand Trade Competition Commission. “Thailand Trade Competition Policy.” Accessed November 10, 2025. https://www.tcct.or.th/view/1/Thailand_Trade_Competition_Policy/EN-US.

Timothy, A. D., and R. Kemala. 2022. “The Relationship between the Concept of Predatory Pricing in the Practice of Price Discounts in the Clothing Convection Industry Through E-Commerce Based on a Business Competition Law Perspective.” Public Scientific Journal 10 (2): 314–322.

Van Gobel, A. 2023. “Analysis of Monopoly Practices and Business Competition in Traditional Markets (Case Study at Kwandang Market).” Egalitaire Law Journal 1 (1): 82–91.

World Bank Group. Country Private Sector Diagnostic: Creating Markets in Thailand – Rebooting Productivity for Resilient Growth. Washington, D.C.: World Bank, 2022. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/468721645451588595/pdf/Country-Private-Sector-Diagnostic-Creating-Markets-in-Thailand-Rebooting-Productivity-for-Resilient-Growth.pdf.

Xu, Min, Jeanne M. David, and Suk Hi Kim. "The fourth industrial revolution: Opportunities and challenges." International journal of financial research 9, no. 2 (2018): 90-95, 10.5430/ijfr.v9n2p90.