Coal Mining: A Comparison of Indonesian and Malaysian Laws
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15294/lslr.v10i2.40247Keywords:
Coal Minerals, Comparative Law, Malaysia IndonesiaAbstract
Malaysia is decentralized, while Indonesia is centralized. However, both countries have natural resources and the right to freely dispose, without interference from other countries. This means that the utilization of coal mining is determined by the policies of each country through regulations. This study is a comparative legal study that raises several issues, namely how state sovereignty over natural resources is regulated in the constitutions of Indonesia and Malaysia, how the coal mining legal systems of the two countries work, and what forms of permits and criminal sanctions are used in the regulation of coal mining in Indonesia and Malaysia. The results of the study show that state sovereignty over Indonesia's natural resources is constitutionally regulated through Article 3 Paragraph (3) of the 1945 Constitution, which states that the earth, water, and natural resources contained therein are controlled by the state for the welfare of the people. Malaysia is constitutionally regulated in Articles 83-91 of the Federal Constitution of the Malay Peninsula of August 31, 1957, which explicitly states that control of land and its management is entrusted to the Malaysian State. The Malaysian coal mining law system is decentralized in terms of licensing, while Indonesia's is centralized and granted by the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, although it was previously decentralized and granted by local governments before the issuance of Law No. 3 of 2020. The types of licenses granted to business actors in Indonesian coal mining law are more varied and not limited to IUPs when compared to the Malaysian state of Selangor. While Indonesia imposes heavier criminal sanctions because they are cumulative with fines, whereas Malaysia imposes alternative sanctions. However, in general, Indonesia's coal mining law system, particularly in terms of licensing, is less consistent compared to Malaysia's law, which has remained decentralized.
References
Ana Duek & Ridwan Rusli, "The natural Resources industry in Decentralised Indonesia: How has Decentralisation Impacted the Mining, Oil and Gas Industries?," DEM Discussion Paper Series 10-25, Department of Economics at the University of Luxembourg, (2010). https://ideas.repec.org/p/luc/wpaper/10-25.html
Andre Noverizky & Faidatul Hikmah, “The Legal Aspects Of Regulating The Submission Of Mining Business Permits In The Perspective Of The Mineral And Coal Mining Law”, UIR Law Review 8, no. 1 (2024). DOI: https://doi.org/10.25299/uirlrev.2024.vol8(1).16539
Azmi & Associates, The Legal Framework Relating to Extraction, Trade and Dealing of Precious Metals, LEXOLOGY, January 2025. https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=0fdfe56d-d5a3-4e73-879f-f1f2c1dc2375#:~:text=The%20management%20and%20regulation%20of,mining%20leases%20and%20enforcing%20compliance.
Cut Asmaul Husna TR, “Adopsi Prinsip Permanent Sovereignty Over Natural Resources (PSNR) Migas”, Jurnal Hukum & Pembangunan 46, no. 4 (2023). DOI: https://doi.org/10.21143/jhp.vol46.no2.74
David A. Jodice “Sources of Change in Third World Regimes for Foreign Direct Investment, 1968–1976”, Jurnal: International Organization 34, no 2 (1980): 177–206. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0020818300018737
Diang Anggraini, “Criminal Law Policy Regarding Criminal Sanctions In Law Number 4 Of 2009 As Amended By Law Number 3 Of 2020 Concerning Mineral And Coal Mining And Law Number 32 Of 2009 Concerning Environmental Protection And Management”, Jurnal Multidisiplin Sahombu 4, no. 2 (2024). DOI10.58471/jms.v4i02
Eric Goh & Shahar Effendi, “Overview of an effective Governance Policy for Mineral Resource Sustainability in Malaysia”, Resources Policy 52, (2017): 1-6. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resourpol.2017.01.012
Fairouz Mustafa, Chima Mordi, Ahmed A. Elamer, “The role of Foreign Direct Investment and Environmental Taxation in Promoting Renewable Energy Sustainability”, Journal of Cleaner Production 505 (2025): 145515. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2025.145515
Indonesia, the Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia 1945.
Indonesia, Law No. 4 of 2009 concerning Mineral and Coal Mining.
Indonesia, Law No. 2 of 2025 concerning Mineral and Coal Mining.
Indonesia, Regulation of the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources (Permen ESDM) No. 15 of 2024.
Ivan Ferdiansyah Agustinus, “Mineral and Coal Mining Business and Management in Indonesia from the Indonesian Constitutional Viewpoint”, Journal of World Science 1, no. 7 (2022), DOI: https://doi.org/10.58344/jws.v1i7.68
Iwan Permadi, “Masalah Regulasi Tanah Negara di Indonesia dan Perbandingan Regulasinya dengan Malaysia”, Proceedings of the 2022 Brawijaya International Conference (BIC 2022), Y. A. Yusran et al. (Eds.): BIC 2022, AEBMR 235 (2023): 352-261. https://doi.org/10.2991/978-94-6463-140-1_35
James N. Hyde “Permanent Sovereignty over Natural Wealth and Resources,” Jurnal: American Journal of International Law 50, no. 4 (1956): 854–867. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/2195626
Jean Bodin, Six Books Of the Commonwealth, translated by M. J. Tooley, Oxford: Kemp Hall Bindery, Without Year, p. 25
Jiyoung Ko & Mi Jeong Shin “Not risky business? Nationalism and foreign direct investment,” Jurnal: The Social Science Journal 63, no 1 (2021): 159–174. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03623319.2021.1996172
Kementerian Energi dan Sumber Daya Mineral, Keputusan Menteri / Peraturan tentang Neraca Sumber Daya dan Cadangan Mineral dan Batubara Nasional. JDIH ESDM, (2024). https://jdih.esdm.go.id/dokumen/download?id=2024abskmesdm132k.pdf&utm_source=chatgpt.com
KPU, Demokrasi Parlementer: Pengertian Ciri Aspek Prinsip dan Penerapanya di Era Modern, 06 Oktober 2025. https://papuapegunungan.kpu.go.id/blog/read/683_demokrasi-parlementer-pengertian-ciri-aspek-prinsip-dan-penerapannya-di-era-modern
Liyana Zainudin, Zaharah Mohd Yusof, Jaiya Abu, “Temporary Land Use Permit in Selangor: An Overview of Land Policies and Practice in the District of Petaling, Malaysia”, Built Environment Journal, Vol. 20, No. 1, 31-39, 2023. https://journal.uitm.edu.my/ojs/index.php/BEJ/article/view/6425/3634
Lon L. Fuller, The Morality of Law, Revised Edition, United States of America, Yale University, 1969.
Luis Suárez Nieto, Gregorio Fidalgo Valverde, Alicja Krzemień, Pedro Riesgo Fernández, Francisco Javier Iglesias Rodríguez, “Economic Risks in Mining Investments: A Prospective Analysis of Capital Cost Estimation in Copper Mining Projects”, Resources Policy 99 (2024): 105427. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resourpol.2024.105427
Malaysia, Malay Federation Constitution of August 31, 1957.
Malaysia, Mineral Development Act 1994.
Malaysia, Mineral Enactment (Selangor) 2000.
Mathieu Blondeel & Thijs Van de Graaf, “Toward a global coal mining moratorium? A comparative analysis of coal mining policies in the USA, China, India and Australia”, Climate Change 150 (2018): 89–101. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10584-017-2135-5
Mehlum, H., Moene, K., & Torvik, R. “Institutions and the Resource Curse” The Economic Journal 116, no. 508 (2006): 1–20. https://www.annualreviews.org/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-resource-100820-092612
Mirian Kene Omalu & Armando Zamora, “Key Issues in Mining Policy: a Brief Comparative Survey on the Reform of Mining Law”, Journal of Energy & Natural Resources Law 17, Issue 1 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1080/02646811.1999.11433154
Mohammad Ashraf Mohamed Sopiee & Syed Zomael Hussain, The Legal Framework Of Mining Industry In Malaysia, Mondag, 26 Juli 2021. https://www.mondaq.com/mining/1095416/the-legal-framework-of-mining-industry-in-malaysia?msg=15#authors
Nelly Pinangkaan, “Makna Pasal 33 UUD 1945 dalam Pembangunan Hukum Ekonomi Indonesia”, Lex Administratum 3, no. 5 (2015). https://ejournal.unsrat.ac.id/index.php/administratum/article/view/18972
Nico Schrijver, Sovereignty Over Natural Resources, Balancing Rights and Dutie, (Cambridge University Press Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, Sao Paulo (1997): 1.
Pui-Kwan Tse, The Mineral Industry of Malaysia, Minerals Yearbook, Area Reports: International 2013, Asia and the Pacific, Vol. 3, (2013). https://books.google.co.id/books?hl=en&lr=&id=aNPvPgq_kpcC&oi=fnd&pg=SA17-PA1&dq=mining+business+permit+Selangor+Malaysia&ots=S8_tp3Td8J&sig=oGW6i6Wr_yfMZgwyBNWhkB2nkRs&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false
Redwan, M. A. F. M., & Besar, J. A. "Pembentukan Kerajaan Persekutuan Majoriti Melayu dan Impaknya Terhadap Tingkah Laku Politik di Kawasan DUN Kajang, Selangor", Jurnal Wacana Sarjana 6, no 1, (2022): 1–14.
Ricardo Pereira & Orla Gough, “Permanent Sovereignty Over Natural Resources in The 21st Century: Natural Resource Governance and the Right to Self-Determination of Indigenous Peoples Under International Law”, Melbourne Journal of International Law 14, (2013): 1-45. https://law.unimelb.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0005/1687487/04PereiraGough-Depaginated.pdf
Setiawan, A. “Minerals and Coal Reserves Potential in Indonesia and the World: Potensi Cadangan Mineral dan Batubara di Indonesia dan Dunia”. INTAN Jurnal Penelitian Tambang 1, no. 1, (2022): 20–31. https://doi.org/10.56139/intan.v1i1.7
Shing Chyi Chua & Tick Hui Oh, “Review on Malaysia's national energy developments: Key policies, Agencies, Programmes and International Involvements”, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, Vol. 14, Issue 9, (2010): 2916-2925. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2010.07.031
Shafruddin Hashim, “The Constitution And The Federal Idea In Peninsula Malaysia”, Journal of Malaysian and Comparative Law 11 (1984).
Sigit Riyanto, “Kedaulatan Negara Dalam Kerangka Hukum Internasional Kontemporer”, Jurnal Yustitia 1, no. 3 (2012): 7 – 8. Diperoleh dari: https://jurnal.uns.ac.id/yustisia/article/view/10074
Sornarajah, M. the International Law on Foreign Investment, Third Edition, Cambridge University Press, New York United States of America, (2010): 53.
Stephanie Chng, “The Federal Constitution of Malaysia: A Kelsenian Perspective”, Asian Journal of Comparative Law 17, Issue 2 (2022).
Suwarsit, S., & Arifardhani, Y. “Role of Divestment: Realizing Welfare Indonesian”, Indian Journal of Law and Justice 14, no. 2, (2023): 1–20. https://ir.nbu.ac.in/handle/123456789/5058
Suwarsit Suwarsit, Heru Sugiyono, Dwi Aryanti Ramadhani, Dwi Desi Yayi Tarina, “The Measuring Effectiveness of Centralization of Indonesian Coal Mineral Mining Licensing”, Law Development Journal 7, no. 3 (2025).
Suwarsit Suwarsit, Heru Sugiyono, Ali Abdullah,Yoyo Arifardhani, Purgito, Ifa Latifa, “Nasionalisasi Saham Asing Pertambangan Mineral Batubara Perwujudan Bela Negara”, Widya Yuridika: Jurnal Hukum 8, no. 3 (2025). https://publishing-widyagama.ac.id/ejournal-v2/index.php/yuridika/article/view/6900
Suwarsit Suwarsit, An-An Chandrawulan, Isis Ikhwansyah, Zainal Mutaqin, “State Regulation and Sovereignty Over the Divestment of Foreign Shares After Changes in the Mining Laws”, Journal of Legal, Ethical and Regulatory Issues 25, Special Issue 1 (2022).
Tim T. Werner, Tessa Toumbourou, Victor Maus, Martin C. Lukas, Laura J. Sonter, Muhamad Muhdar, Rebecca K. Runting & Anthony Bebbington, “Patterns of Infringement, Risk, and Impact Driven by Coal Mining Permits in Indonesia”, Ambio 53 (2024): 242–256. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13280-023-01944-y
Tundjung Herning Sitabuana, Hukum Tata Negara Indonesia (1st ed.) Jakarta: Konstitusi Press (2020): 97
United Nations, The UN Secretary-General's Panel on Critical Energy Transition Minerals, https://www.un.org/en/climatechange/critical-minerals?_gl=1*pmhrs9*_ga*MTM0NTE3MDA0NS4xNzA5MTUwNjUz*_ga_TK9BQL5X7Z*MTczOTU0MDYwMy4zNy4wLjE3Mzk1NDA2MDUuMC4wLjA.
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development Environmental Legislation for the Mining and Metals Industries in Asia, 1994, page 15. https://unctad.org/system/files/official-document/pocomd40.en.pdf
Zainudin Hasan, Sanyyah Majidah, Aldi Yansah, Rahmi Fitrinoviana Salsabila, Made Sera Wirantika, “Konstitusi Sebagai Dasar Hukum Dalam Pembangunan Sistem Hukum Nasional“, JIMA: Jurnal Ilmiah Mahasiswa, Research Findings, Literature Review, and Systematic Review 2, no. 1, January-June (2024). https://ejournal.penerbitjurnal.com/index.php/JIMA/article/view/745
Zico Junius Fernando, Beni Kurnia Illahi, Yagie Sagita Putra & Ikhbal Gusri, “Deep Anti-corruption Blueprint Mining, Mineral, and Coal Sector in Indonesia”, Cogent Social Sciences 9, no. 1, (2023): 2187737. DOI: 10.1080/23311886.2023.2187737
Downloads
Published
Article ID
40247Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Suwarsit Suwarsit (Author)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
All writings published in this journal are personal views of the authors and do not represent the view of this journal and the author's affiliated institutions. Authors retain the copyrights under this license, see our copyrights notice.
