Forign Ownership and Bank Performance: Evidence From Indonesia

Amarilla Hapsari, Rofikoh Rokhim


The main objective of this study is to examine the impact of foreign entry on the domestic bank-ing markets profitability and overhead costs as financial sector FDI is a relatively new phenom-enon and typically takes the form of banks in industrialized countries establishing branches and facilities in developing countries. A panel data covering the period from 2000 to 2012 is set based on the financial data from 82 commercial banks, which operated in Indonesia as of De-cember 2012 and represented 92 percent of the commercial banks total assets. The results of this study are expected to complement the existing collection of studies on the foreign penetra-tion in the Indonesian banking industry, as to date there has been limited study of the impact of foreign ownership on bank performance in Indonesia. From a policy perspective, this study draws some conclusions which clarify the impacts of foreign penetration on banking industry. The government should continue to open the banking market up to foreign investors if they are proven to bring a positive impact, and should act conversely if they are proven to have an adverse impact on the local banking sector.


Banking; Foreign Ownership; Indonesia.

Full Text:



Bayyurt, N. 2013. Ownership Effect on Banks Performance:

Multi Criteria Decision Making

Approaches on Foreign and Domestic Turkish

Banks. ProFedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences.

: 919928.

Berger, A. N & Hannan, H. 1989. The Price-Concentration

Relationship In Banking. The

Review of Economics and Statistics. 71 (2):


Berger, A. N., Clarke, G. R. G., Cull, R., Klapper, L

& Udell, G. F. 2005. Corporate Governance

And Bank Performance: A Joint Analysis Of

The Static, Selection, And Dynamic Effects

Of Domestic, Foreign, And State Ownership.

Journal of Banking and Finance. 29 (8):


Berger, A. N., DeYoung, R., Genay, H & Udell, G. F.

Globalization of financial institutions:

Evidence from cross-border banking performance.

Brookings-Wharton Papers on Financial

Services, 2000 (1): 23120.

Binhadi. 1995. Financial Sector Deregulation, Banking

Development, and Monetary Policy the

Indonesian Experience. Institute Bankir Indonesia,


Blomstrm, M., Kokko, A & Zejan, M. 2000. Foreign

Direct Investment: Firm and Host Country

Strategies. St. Martin Press Inc., New York.

Bruno, V & Hauswald, R. (2009). The Real Effect

Jurnal Dinamika Manajemen, 8 (1) 2017, 30-43

of Foreign Banks. World. Retrieved from

Chen, S. H & Liao, C. C. 2011. Are Foreign Banks

More Profitable Than Domestic Banks?

Home- And Host-Country Effects Of Banking

Market Structure, Governance, And Supervision.

Journal of Banking and Finance. 35

(4): 819839.

Claessens, S. 2009. Competition In The Financial

Sector: Overview Of Competition Policies.

World Bank Research Observer.

Claessens, S., Demirg-Kunt, A & Huizinga, H.

How Does Foreign Entry Affect Domestic

Banking Markets? Journal of Banking

and Finance. 25 (5): 891911.

Claessens, S & Laeven, L. 2004. What Drives Bank

Competition? Some International Evidence.

Journal of Money, Credit and Banking. 36 (3):


Crystal, J. S., Dages, B. G & Goldberg, L. S. 2002.

Has Foreign Bank Entry Led To Sounder

Banks In Latin America?. Current Issues in

Economics and Finance. 8 (1): 16.

Demirg-Kunt, A., Laeven, L & Levine, R. 2004.

Regulations, Market Structure, Institutions,

And The Cost Of Financial Intermediation.

Journal of Money, Credit and Banking. 36 (3):


Deyoung, R & Nolle, D. E. 1996. Foreign-Owned

Banks in the United States: Earning Market

Share or Buying It?. Journal of Money, Credit

and Banking. 28 (4): 622.

Focarelli, D & Pozzolo, A. 2005. Where Do Banks

Expand Abroad? An Empirical Analysis

Where Do Banks Expand Abroad? An Empirical

Analysis. Source: The Journal of Business.

(6): 24352464.

Goldberg, L. S. 2007. Financial Sector FDI and Host

Countries: New and Old Lessons. FRBNY

Economic Policy Review. 3: 117.

Hamada, M. 2003. Transformation of the Financial

Sector in Indonesia. IDE Research Paper. 6.

Haryanto, S. 2016. Profitability Identification Of

National Banking Through Credit, Capital,

Capital Structure, Efficiency, And Risk Level.

Jurnal Dinamika Manajemen. 7 (1): 11-21.

Hasan, I & Hunter, W. 1996. Efficiency of Japanese

multinational banks in the United States. Research

in Finance. JAI Press, Greenwich. 157-

Herrero, A & Simon, D. 2003. Financial FDI to

Emerging Economies from the Home Countrys

Perspective: a submitted for publication

of the Literature. CGFS Publications, 22,

Bank for International Settlements, Basel,


Hryckiewicz, A & Kowalewski, O. 2010. Economic

Determinates, Financial Crisis And Entry

Modes Of Foreign Banks Into Emerging

Markets. Emerging Markets Review. 11 (3):


Hudgins, S. C & Rose, P. S. 2010. Bank Management

and Financial Services. New York: McGraw


Hymer, S. H. 1960. The International Operations

of National Firms: A Study of Direct Foreign

Investment. MITPress: Cambridge, MA.

Jeon, B. N., Olivero, M. P & Wu, J. 2011. Do Foreign

Banks Increase Competition? Evidence

From Emerging Asian And Latin American

Banking Markets. Journal of Banking and Finance.

(4): 856875.

Jiang, C., Yao, S & Feng, G. 2013. Bank Ownership,

Privatization, And Performance: Evidence

From A Transition Country. Journal of Banking

and Finance. 37 (9): 33643372.

Lin, X & Zhang, Y. 2009. Bank Ownership Reform

And Bank Performance In China. Journal of

Banking and Finance. 33 (1): 2029.

Lu, C. H., Shen, C. H & Wu, M. W. 2009. Impact

of Foreign Bank Entry on the Performance of

Chinese Banks. China & World Economy. 17

(3): 102-121.

Manlagit, M. C. 2011. The Economic Effects Of

Foreign Bank Presence: Evidence From The

Philippines. Journal of International Money

and Finance. 30: 1180-1194.

Mester, L. J. 1996. A Study Of Bank Efficiency Taking

Into Account Risk-Preferences. Journal of

Banking and Finance. 20 (6): 10251045.

Micco, A., Panizza, U & Yanez, M. 2007. Bank Ownership

And Performance. Does Politics Matter?

Journal of Banking and Finance. 31 (1):


Morgan, D. P & Strahan, P. E. 2004. Foreign Bank

Entry And Business Volatility: Evidence

From US States And Other Countries. Banking

Market Structure and Monetary Policy,

Central Bank of Chile, Santiago.

Naaborg, I., Scholtens, B., De Haan, J., Bol, H & De

Haas, R. 2004. How Important Are Foreign

Banks In The Financial Development Of

Amarilla Hapsari & Rofikoh Rokhim / Forign Ownership and Bank Performance:...

European Transition Countries. Journal of

Emerging Market Finance. 3: 99-123.

Nagano, M. 2016. The Bank-Firm Relationship

During Economic Transition: The Impacts

On Bank Performance In Emerging Economies.

Emerging Markets Review. 28: 117 - 139

Nasution, A. 1996. Financial Institutions and Policies

in Indonesia. Institute of Southeast Asian

Studies, Singapore.

Northcott, C. 2004. Competition In Banking: A Review

Of The Literature. Working Paper, Bank

of Canada, 2004-24.

Okuda, H & Rungsomboon, S. 2006. Comparative

Cost Study Of Foreign And Thai Domestic

Banks In 1990-2002: Its Policy Implications

For A Desirable Banking Industry Structure.

Journal of Asian Economics. 17 (4): 714737.

Olievero, M. P., Li, Y & Jeon, B. N. 2009. Consolidation

In Banking And The Lending Channel

Of Monetary Transmission: Evidence From

Asia And Latin America. Working Paper, LeBow

College of Business, Drexel University.

Rao, A. 2005. Cost Frontier Efficiency And Risk-

Return Analysis In An Emerging Market.

International Review of Financial Analysis. 14

(3): 283303.

Rokhim, R & Susanto, A. P. 2013. The Increase Of

Foreign Ownership And Its Impact On The

Performance, Competition And Risk In The

Indonesian Banking Industry. Asian Journal

of Business and Accounting. 6 (2): 139155.

Sato, Y. 2005. Bank Restructuring and Financial Institution

Reform in Indonesia. The Developing

Economies. XLIII (1): 91-120.

Thi, N & Vencappa, D. 2007. Does the Entry Mode

of Foreign Banks Matter for Bank Efficiency?

Evidence from Czech Republic, Hungary,

and Poland. Manuscript, Nottingham University

Business School, University of Nottingham,

United Kingdom.

Unite, A & Sullivan, M. 2003. The Effect Of Foreign

Entry And Ownership Structure On

The Philippines Domestic Banking Market.

Journal of Banking and Finance. 27: 2323-

Wardhana, A. 1995. Financial Reform: Achievement,

Problems, And Prospects, In Indonesia

Assessment 1994 Finance As A Key Sector

In Indonesias Development. Institute of

Southeast Asian Studies, Singapore.

Williams, J & Nguyen, N. 2005. Financial Liberalisation,

Crisis, And Restructuring: A Comparative

Study Of Bank Performance And Bank

Governance In South East Asia. Journal of

Banking and Finance. 29: 21192154.

World Bank. 1986. The Philippines a Framework for

Economic Recovery. The World Bank, Washington


World Bank. 2006. Global Development Finance. The

World Bank, Washington DC.

Woo, G & Nasution. 1994. Macroeconomic policies,

Crisis, and Long-Term Growth in Indonesia.

The World Bank, Washington DC.

Wu, J., Leon, B. N & Luca, A. 2010. Foreign Bank

Penetration, Resource Allocation And Economic

Growth: Evidence From Emerging

Economies. Journal of Economic Integration.

(1): 166-192.

Yildirim, H. S & Philippatos, G. C. 2007. Restructuring,

Consolidation And Competition In

Latin American Banking Markets. Journal of

Banking and Finance. 31 (3): 629639.

View Counter: Abstract - 181 and PDF - 149


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Add comment