A Theoretical Framework for Evaluation of Musical Topics: The Case of Chopin
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15294/harmonia.v25i1.23083Keywords:
musical semiotics; musical topic; musical signification; Chopin; PeirceAbstract
Peircean’ semiotics provides a cognitive framework for investigating the general process of thinking, expressed as a semiosis with multiple vectors. With their diverse expressions and connotations, musical topics inherently embody semiotic principles in musicological discourse, though debates persist regarding their semiotic references. This study presents a complementary model founded on Peirce’s tripartite semiotic framework in an attempt to account for the representation of musical topics and facilitate an approach to topical evaluation. Among other things, Peirce’s concept of correlates motivates the contemplation of topics with similar expressive qualities. In the process of unpacking, the paper considers the complex challenges and potential solutions to evaluating musical topics posed by their multiple referential layers. The analytical framework synthesizes Ratner’s rhetorical reduction approach to analyzing Romantic music with Grimalt’s topic categorization system. This approach is then applied to evaluate the nocturne topic in the secondary theme of the first movement of Chopin’s Piano Sonata No. 3 in B minor, with Chopin’s Barcarolle serving as a correlate to examine the effect of the nocturne topic. The semiotic-based topical evaluation demonstrates the effectiveness of this approach while raising critical awareness in topic theory discourse.
References
Agawu, V. K. (1991). Playing with signs: a semiotic interpretation of classic music. Princeton University Press.
Agawu, V. K. (2001). The challenge of semiotics. In N. Cook & M. Everist (Eds.), Rethinking Music (Reprinted, pp. 138–160). Oxford University Press.
Agawu, V. K. (2008). Topic theory: Achievement, critique, prospects. In L. Lütteken & H.-J. Hinrichsen (Eds.), Passagen: IMS Kongress Zürich 2007, fünf Hauptvorträge / five keynote speeches (pp. 38–69). Bärenreiter.
Agawu, V. K. (2009). Music as discourse: Semiotic adventures in Romantic music. Oxford University Press.Allanbrook, W. J. (1983). Rhythmic Gesture in Mozart: Le Nozze Di Figaro & Don Giovanni. University of Chicago Press.
Allanbrook, W. J. (2002). Theorizing the comic surface. In A. Giger & T. J. Mathiesen (Eds.), Music in the mirror: Reflections on the history of music theory and literature for the 21st century (Vol. 3, pp. 195–216). University of Nebraska Press.
Allanbrook, W. J. (2014). The secular commedia: Comic mimesis in late eighteenth-century music (M. A. Smart & R. Taruskin, Eds.). University of California Press.
Atkin, A. (2023). Peirce’s theory of signs. In E. N. Zalta & U. Nodelman (Eds.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Spring 2023 ed.). Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University. https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2023/entries/peirce-semiotics/
Bastian, H. C. (1880). The brain as an organ of mind. D. Appleton and Company.
Bellman, J. (1995). Aus alten märchen: the chivalric style of schumann and brahms. The Journal of Musicology, 13(1), 117–135. https://doi.org/10.2307/764054
Brossard, S. de. (1740). A musical dictionary (J. Grassineau, Trans.). Printed for J. Wilcox.
Caplin, W. E. (2005). On the relation of musical topoi to formal function. Eighteenth Century Music, 2(1), 113–124. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1478570605000278
Chandler, D. (2022). Semiotics: The Basics (4th ed.). Routledge.
Chopin, F. (2009a). Barcarolle op. 60 [musical score] (J. Z. Zhu, J. Wang, & Y. Zou, Trans.). In J. Ekier (Ed.), Various Works (Urtext, pp. 90–100). Shanghai Music Publishing House.
Chopin, F. (2009b). Sonata op. 58 [musical score] (J. Z. Zhu, J. Wang, & Y. Zou, Trans.). In J. Ekier (Ed.), Sonatas (Urtext, pp. 38–81). Shanghai Music Publishing House.
Cooke, D. (1959). The language of music. Oxford University Press.
Dahlhaus, C. (1982). Esthetics of music (W. W. Austin, Trans.). Cambridge University Press.
Dahlhaus, C. (1983). Foundations of music history (J. B. Robinson, Trans.). Cambridge University Press.
Dahlhaus, C. (1985). Realism in nineteenth-century music (M. Whittall, Trans.). Cambridge University Press.
Dahlhaus, C., & Eggebrecht, H. H. (1979). Brockhaus riemann musiklexikon (Vol. 2). Brockhaus.
DeLong, K. (2016). Revisiting Schubert’s Czech connections. In L. B. Bodley & B. M. Reul (Eds.), The Unknown Schubert (pp. 219–230). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315085012
Dickensheets, J. (2003). Nineteenth-century topical Analysis: A Lexicon of Romantic Topoi. The Pendragon Review, 2(1), 5–19.
Dickensheets, J. (2012). The topical vocabulary of the nineteenth century. Journal of Musicological Research, 31(2–3), 97–137.
Donaldson, J. (2024). Kaleidoscopic topics in the music of György Ligeti and Thomas Adès. Music Theory Online, 30(2). https://mtosmt.org/issues/mto.24.30.2/mto.24.30.2.donaldson.html
Dougherty, W. P., & Sheinberg, E. (2022). Semiotics in music and musicology. In J. Pelkey, S. Petrilli, & S. M. Ricciardone (Eds.), Semiotics in the arts and social sciences (Vol. 3, pp. 187–205). Bloomsbury Academic.
Everett, Y. U. (2020). Pianto as a topical signifier of grief in contemporary operas by John Adams, Thomas Adès, and Kaija Saariaho. In E. Sheinberg & W. P. Dougherty (Eds.), The Routledge handbook of music signification (pp. 333–344). Routledge.
Fabbri, F. (1999). Browsing music spaces: categories and the musical mind. 14. https://www.tagg.org/others/ffabbri9907.html
Fallows, D. (2001). Cantabile. In S. Sadie & J. Tyrrell (Eds.), The New Grove dictionary of music and musicians (2nd ed., Vol. 5, p. 8). Macmillan.
Fontanier, P. (1968). Les figures du discours. Flammarion.
Frymoyer, J. (2017). The musical topic in the twentieth century: A Case Study of Schoenberg’s Ironic Waltzes. Music Theory Spectrum, 39(1), 83–108. https://doi.org/10.1093/mts/mtx004
Grimalt, J. (2020). Mapping musical signification. Springer International Publishing.
Hatten, R. S. (1994). Musical meaning in beethoven: Markedness, correlation, and interpretation. Indiana University Press.
Hatten, R. S. (1998). Music theory and general semiotics: a creative interaction. In R. Kevelson (Ed.), Hi-fives: A trip to semiotics (pp. 71–84). Peter Lang.
Hatten, R. S. (2005). Four Semiotic Approaches to Musical Meaning: Markedness, Topics, Tropes, and Gesture. Musicological Annual, 41(1), 5–30. https://doi.org/10.4312/mz.41.1.5-30
Hatten, R. S. (2018). A theory of virtual agency for western art music (R. S. Hatten, Ed.). Indiana University Press, Office of Scholarly Publishing.
Hatten, R. S. (2023). Toward An Adequate Theoretical Framework for interpreting Complex Signification In Music. The American Journal of Semiotics, 39(1/4), 135–148. https://doi.org/10.5840/ajs202372087
Hausman, C. R. (1987). Metaphorical Reference and Peirce’s Dynamical Object. Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society, 23(3), 381–409.
Hjelmslev, L. (1969). Prolegomena to A Theory of Language (F. J. Whitfield, Trans.). University of Wisconsin Press.
Horton, J. (2014). Listening to Topics in The Nineteenth Century. In D. Mirka (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Topic Theory (pp. 1–28). Oxford University Press.
Horton, J. (2020). On The Musicological Necessity of Musical Analysis. The Musical Quarterly, 103(1–2), 62–104. https://doi.org/10.1093/musqtl/gdaa005
Huneker, J. (2008). Chopin: The Man and His Music. The Floating Press.
Kallberg, J. (1988). The Rhetoric of Genre: Chopin’s Nocturne in G Minor. 19th-Century Music, 11(3), 238–261. https://doi.org/10.2307/746322
Kim, J. H. (2023). Kinaesthetic Musical Imagery Underlying Music Cognition. In M. B. Küssner, L. Taruffi, & G. A. Floridou (Eds.), Music and Mental Imagery (pp. 54–63). Taylor & Francis.
Klein, M. L. (2005). Intertextuality in Western Art Music. Indiana University Press.
Klein, M. L. (2022). A Pitch-Class Motive as a Lacanian Symptom in Prokofiev’s Piano Sonata No. 6. Primeira Sessão do Ciclo de Encontros Virtuais da TeMA de 2022, Youtube.
Lakoff, G., & Turner, M. (1989). More Than Cool Reason: A Field Guide to Poetic Metaphor. University of Chicago Press.
Leichtentritt, H. (1922). Analyse Der Chopin’schen Klavierwerke [analysis of Chopin’s Piano Works] (Vol. 2). Max Hesses Verlag.
Martinet, A. (1960). Elements of General Linguistics (E. Palmer, Trans.). The University of Chicago Press.
Mirka, D. (2014). Introduction. In D. Mirka (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Topic Theory (pp. 1–57). Oxford University Press.
Monelle, R. (2000). The Sense of Music: Semiotic Essays. Princeton University Press.
Monelle, R. (2014). Linguistics and Semiotics in Music. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315076942
Niecks, F. (1902). Frederick Chopin: As A Man and Musician (3rd ed., Vol. 2). Novello.
Palisca, C. V. (1983). The genesis of mattheson’s style classification. In G. J. Buelow & H. J. Marx (Eds.), New Mattheson Studies (pp. 409–423). Cambridge University Press.
Parakilas, J. (2017). The Barcarolle and The Barcarolle: Topic And Genre in Chopin. In J. Bellman & H. Goldberg (Eds.), Chopin and His World (pp. 231–248). Princeton University Press.
Pascall, R. (2001). Style. In S. Sadie & J. Tyrrell (Eds.), The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians (2nd ed., Vol. 24, p. 638). Macmillan.
Peirce, C. S. (1896). Logic of Mathematics: An attempt to develop my categories from within [MS 900].
Peirce, C. S. (1901). Dictionary of Philosophy and Psychology. In J. M. Baldwin (Ed.), Index (in exact logic) (Vol. 1, pp. 531–532, CP 2.306). Macmillan and Co.
Peirce, C. S. (1903). Logical Tracts. No. 2. On Existential Graphs, Euler’s Diagrams, and Logical Algebra [MS 492].
Peirce, C. S. (1904). Letters to Lady Welby [MS L463].
Peirce, C. S. (1905). Adirondack Summer School Lectures [MS 1334].
Peirce, C. S. (1906). Prolegomena to An Apology for Pragmaticism. The Monist, 16(4), 492–546. https://doi.org/10.5840/monist190616436
Peirce, C. S. (1908). Letters to Lady Welby [MS L463].
Peirce, C. S. (1909). Letters to William James [MS L224].
Peirce, C. S. (1931). The Collected Works of Charles Sanders Peirce (C. Hartshorne & P. Weiss, Eds.; Vol. 1). Harvard University Press.
Peirce, C. S. (1932). The Collected Works of Charles Sanders Peirce (C. Hartshorne & P. Weiss, Eds.; Vol. 2). Harvard University Press.
Peirce, C. S. (1933). The Collected Works of Charles Sanders Peirce (C. Hartshorne & P. Weiss, Eds.; Vol. 4). Harvard University Press.
Peirce, C. S. (1955). Philosophical Writings of Peirce (J. Buchler, Ed.). Dover Publications.
Peirce, C. S. (1958). The Collected Works of Charles Sanders Peirce (A. W. Burks, Ed.; Vol. 8). Harvard University Press.
Peirce, C. S. (1992). The Essential Peirce: Selected Philosophical Writings (N. Houser & C. Kloesel, Eds.; Vol. 1). Indiana University Press.
Peirce, C. S. (1998). The Essential Peirce: Selected Philosophical Writings (Peirce Edition Project, Ed.; Vol. 2). Indiana University Press.
Peirce, C. S. (2013). Immediate Object. In M. Bergman & S. Paavola (Eds.), The Commens Dictionary: Peirce’s Terms in His Own Words (New Edition). http://www.commens.org/dictionary/entry/quote-letters-lady-welby-35
Plato. (1997). Plato: Complete Works (J. M. Cooper, Ed.). Hackett Publishing.
Ratner, L. G. (1966). Music: The Listener’s Art (2nd ed.). McGraw-Hill.
Ratner, L. G. (1980). Classic Music: Expression, Form, and Style. Schirmer Books.
Ratner, L. G. (1992). Romantic Music: Sound and Syntax. Schirmer Books.
Rosen, C. (2010). Music and Sentiment. Yale University Press.
Rousseau, J.-J. (1990). The First and Second Discourses together with The Replies To Critics And Essay On The Origin of Languages (V. Gourevitch, Ed. & Trans.). Harper & Row.
Rumph, S. (2014). Topical Figurae: The Double Articulation of Topics. In D. Mirka (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Topic Theory (pp. 493–513). Oxford University Press.
Samson, J. (2001a). Chopin, Past and Present. Early Music, 29(3), 381–387.
Samson, J. (2001b). Genre. In S. Sadie & J. Tyrrell (Eds.), The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians (2nd ed., Vol. 9, p. 657). Macmillan.
Saussure, F. de. (1959). Course in General Linguistics (C. Bally & A. Sechehaye, Eds.; W. Baskin, Trans.). Philosophical Library.
Tarasti, E. (1994). A Theory of Musical Semiotics. Indiana University Press.
Tarasti, E. (2002). Signs of Music: A Guide to Musical Semiotics. Mouton de Gruyter.
Tarasti, E. (2016). Metaphors, semiotics and futures studies. Futures, 84, 120–123. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.futures.2016.04.003
Tarasti, E. (2023). Topics and Music Performance: Some Reflections and a Proposal for a Theory. In J. Hellaby (Ed.), Musical Topics and Musical Performance. Routledge.
Tarasti, E., Hatten, R. S., Karbusicky, V., Stoianova, I., Charles, D., Kurkela, K., Nielsen, F. V., Pierce, A., Hosokawa, S., Camilleri, L., Makela, T., & Jiranek, J. (1987). Basic Concepts of Studies in Musical Signification: A Report On A New International Research Project In Semiotics Of Music. In T. A. Sebeok & J. Umiker-Sebeok (Eds.), The Semiotic Web 1986 (pp. 405–581). Mouton de Gruyter.
Tomaszewski, M. (2015). Chopin: The Man, His Work and Its Resonance (J. Comber, Ed. & Trans.). The Fryderyk Chopin Institute.
Weber, M. (1949). The Methodology of the Social Sciences (E. A. Shils & H. A. Finch, Trans.). Free Press.
Zhao, Y. (2017). 指示性是符号的第一性 [Indexicality Is the Firstness in Semiotics]. Journal of Shanghai University (Social Sciences), 34(6), 104–113.
Zlatev, J., Madsen, E. A., Lenninger, S., Persson, T., Sayehli, S., Sonesson, G., & van de Weijer, J. (2013). Understanding Communicative intentions and Semiotic Vehicles By Children And Chimpanzees. Cognitive Development, 28(3), 312–329. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cogdev.2013.05.001
