Legal Gaps in Apartment Law: The Gading Nias Case and Urban Spatial Planning Challenges
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15294/jal.v1i1.31075Keywords:
Spatial Planning, Apartment Law, Urban Planning, Legal Framework, Agrarian ReformAbstract
This paper investigates the legal complexities in implementing the Apartment law within the Gading Nias Residence, one of the largest and densest vertical housing complexes in North Jakarta. The Apartment law, which distinguishes between individual ownership of apartment units and collective ownership of common areas and land, has faced significant challenges in this context. These challenges include delays in the formation of the Association of Apartment Owners and Occupants (PPPSRS), conflicts between residents and developers, and ambiguity surrounding land rights, which has left many residents without legal certainty regarding their units. Through a normative legal approach, combined with empirical case studies, this research examines the relevant laws and regulations, as well as the practical legal issues encountered on the ground. The study also explores the broader implications of these legal challenges on urban spatial planning, with particular emphasis on zoning inconsistencies, infrastructure strain, and the relationship with the Agrarian Reform policy under Presidential Regulation No. 62 of 2023. The analysis identifies weak government oversight and legal indecisiveness in the implementation of collective land rights as key contributors to the legal issues in Gading Nias. The paper concludes by recommending enhanced government oversight, accelerated land rights certification, and increased legal awareness among residents as critical solutions. This research contributes to the development of more effective legal frameworks and governance structures for vertical housing in Indonesia, highlighting the urgency of addressing these gaps amid rapid urbanization.
References
Adianto, Joko, et al. "The complexity of contextuality: A case study on vertical housing facilities in Surabaya, Indonesia." Environment and Urbanization ASIA 13.1 (2022): 99-112.
Alden Wily, Liz. "Collective land ownership in the 21st century: Overview of global trends." Land 7.2 (2018): 68.
Alzamzami, Jefri, and Leli Joko Suryono. "Pelaksanaan Perjanjian Sewa Menyewa Rumah Susun dan Akibat Hukumnya dalam hal Terjadi Wanprestasi." Media of Law and Sharia 2.3 (2021): 238-253.
Ariq, Muhammad, and Elsi Kartika Sari. "Perbandingan Peraturan Pemerintah Nomor 4 Tahun 1988 Tentang Rumah Susun dengan Peraturan Pemerintah Nomor 13 Tahun 2021 Tentang Penyelenggaraan Rumah Susun." Metrik Serial Humaniora dan Sains 2.2 (2021): 84-89.
Bangsawan, Mohammad Indra, Arief Budiono, and Dewi Kusuma Diarti. "Prophetic Law-based Land Bank Policy Reformulation in Indonesia." WSEAS Transactions on Systems 21 (2022): 304-311.
Bossuyt, Daniël. "Who owns collaborative housing? A conceptual typology of property regimes." Housing, Theory and Society 39.2 (2022): 200-216.
Chandranegara, Ibnu Sina, and Syaiful Bakhri. "Tindakan Hukum Pemerintah Dalam Pembinaan Pengelolaan Rumah Susun Milik Sebagai Pemenuhan Hak Atas Tempat Tinggal." Jurnal Ius Constituendum 6.2 (2021): 269-283.
Devita, Seventina Monda. "Perkembangan Hak Pengelolaan Atas Tanah Sebelum dan Sesudah Peraturan Pemerintah Nomor 18 tahun 2021 Tentang Hak pengelolaan, Hak Atas Tanah, Satuan Rumah Susun, dan Pendaftaran Tanah." Jurnal hukum Lex generalis 2.9 (2021): 870-888.
Edelman, David J., and Diah Setyorini Gunawan. "Managing the urban environment of Jakarta, Indonesia." Current Urban Studies 8.01 (2020): 57.
Firman, Tommy. "Major issues in Indonesia's urban land development." Land Use Policy 21.4 (2004): 347-355.
Furqon, Muhammad, and Muhammad Habib. "Legal Aspects of Flat Ownership in Indonesia." International Asia of Law and Money Laundering (IAML) 1.3 (2022): 181-186.
Goldblum, Charles, and Tai-Chee Wong. "Growth, crisis and spatial change: a study of haphazard urbanisation in Jakarta, Indonesia." Land Use Policy 17.1 (2000): 29-37.
Graham, Stephen. "Luxified skies: How vertical urban housing became an elite preserve." City 19.5 (2015): 618-645.
Gunawan, Christina Herawati, and Hasni Hasni. "Problematika Pembentukan Perhimpunan Pemilik dan Penghuni Satuan Rumah Susun (PPPSRS) Ditinjau dari Undang-Undang Nomor 20 Tahun 2011 Tentang Rumah Susun (Contoh Kasus Putusan Pengadilan Negeri 553/Pdt. G/2016/PN. JKT. UTR.)." Jurnal Hukum Adigama 3.1 (2020): 46-70.
Hartono, Andy. "Kepemilikan Hak Milik Atas Satuan Rumah Susun." Jurnal Rechtens 2.1 (2013): 1-11.
Hudalah, Delik, and Johan Woltjer. "Spatial planning system in transitional Indonesia." International Planning Studies 12.3 (2007): 291-303.
Izzattisselim, Azisyiah. "Pembentukan Perhimpunan Pemilik Dan Penghuni Satuan Rumah Susun Menuju Kepastian Hukum Penghuni Rumah Susun." Law Review 18.3 (2019): 366.
Jones, Paul. "Formalizing the informal: Understanding the position of informal settlements and slums in sustainable urbanization policies and strategies in Bandung, Indonesia." Sustainability 9.8 (2017): 1436.
Laksono, Muchammad Agung, Ronny Winarno, and Istijab Istijab. "Tinjauan Yuridis Proses Peralihan Hak Guna Bangunan Menjadi Hak Milik Menurut Peraturan Pemerintah Republik Indonesia Nomor 18 Tahun 2021 Tentang Hak Pengelolaan, Hak Atas Tanah, Satuan Rumah Susun dan Pendaftaran Tanah." Yurijaya: Jurnal Ilmiah Hukum 5.2 (2023): 39-54.
Ling, Loa Mei. "Institusi sosial: Perannya dalam keberlangsungan ruang publik terpadu ramah anak di Jakarta." Jurnal Muara sains, Teknologi, Kedokteran dan Ilmu Kesehatan 3.2 (2019): 193-200.
Liong, Ju Tjung, et al. "Space grabs: Colonizing the vertical city." International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 44.6 (2020): 1072-1082.
Mahfud, Muh Afif. "Progressive Agrarian Law as a Concept to Attain Social Justice." Pandecta Research Law Journal 17.1 (2022): 158-166.
Maksum, Muhammad. "Building flats through waqf land: legal breakthrough and obstacles." AHKAM: Jurnal Ilmu Syariah 17.1 (2017): 47-64.
Manaf, Asnawi, Lidya P. Ginting, and Mirza Irwansyah. "The Relevance of Vertical Housing to the Socio-Economic Characteristics of Occupants in Semarang City, Indonesia: Particularly the Proximity of Public Facility Aspects." IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science. Vol. 1264. No. 1. IOP Publishing, 2023.
Natasari, E., et al. "Professional and moral responsibilities of notaries in supporting development in Medan City." IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science. Vol. 452. No. 1. IOP Publishing, 2020.
Nethercote, Megan. "Theorising vertical urbanisation." City 22.5-6 (2018): 657-684.
Nirwana, Ridwan, and Anita Kamilah. "Overview of Home Ownership Law for Foreigners in the Context of a Second Home in Indonesia." Journal of Law and Border Protection 4.2 (2022): 113-124.
Pandia, Tri Putra Asa. Perbuatan Melawan Hukum Dalam Pembentukan Perhimpunan Pemilik Dan Penghuni Satuan Rumah Susun (PPPSRS). Diss. Universitas Medan Area, 2016.
Patanroi, Berlinaldo. "Addressing Multi-Unit Residential Management Conflicts: A Legal Study." Rechtsidee 11.2 (2023): 10-21070.
Quigley, John M., and Larry A. Rosenthal. "The effects of land use regulation on the price of housing: What do we know? What can we learn?." Cityscape (2005): 69-137.
Rachmawati, Farida, Connie Susilawati, and Ashantha Goonetilleke. "An affordability review for low-cost apartment rent." Proceedings of the 2018 Joint Asia-Pacific Network for Housing Research (APNHR) Conference and the Australasian Housing Researchers Conference (AHRC). Griffith University, 2018.
Raslanas, Saulius, Jurgita Alchimovienė, and Nerija Banaitienė. "Residential areas with apartment houses: analysis of the condition of buildings, planning issues, retrofit strategies and scenarios." International Journal of Strategic Property Management 15.2 (2011): 152-172.
Rustiadi, Ernan, and Dyah Retno Panaju. "Spatial pattern of suburbanization and land-use change process: case study in Jakarta suburb." Land Use Changes in Comparative Perspective. CRC Press, 2002. 33-52.
Salain, Made Suksma Prijandhini Devi, I. Palguna, and I. Widiatedja. "The Regulation of the Ownership of Flats by Foreigners after the Enactment of the Job Creation Law." Indonesia Law Review 12.1 (2022): 1-16.
Salim, Wilmar, and Delik Hudalah. "Urban governance challenges and reforms in Indonesia: towards a new Urban Agenda." New urban agenda in Asia-Pacific: Governance for sustainable and inclusive cities. Singapore: Springer Singapore, 2019, pp. 163-181.
Salipu, Amir, et al. Pengantar Perumahan dan Permukiman Tinjauan tentang Standar dan Aturan dalam Perencanaan Pembangunan Permukiman Modern dan Tradisional. Deepublish, 2023.
Setiaprameswari, Dwiluna. "Kewenangan Pemerintah Daerah dalam Pelaksanaan Pengawasan terhadap Perhimpunan Pemilik dan Penghuni Satuan Rumah Susun." Journal Evidence of Law 2.3 (2023): 1-7.
Setiawati, Anda. "Shifting the Concept of Flats Ownership in Indonesia." 3rd Borobudur International Symposium on Humanities and Social Science 2021 (BIS-HSS 2021). Atlantis Press, 2022.
Setiawati, Anda. "Upaya Hukum Terkait Masalah Penjualan Rumah Susun Yang Diikat Dengan PPJB." Hukum Pidana dan Pembangunan Hukum 1.2 (2019).
Solehuddin, Solehuddin. "The proprietary rights status of the apartment units held by foreign nationals in Job Creation Law." Legality: Jurnal Ilmiah Hukum 30.1 (2022): 88-102.
Sudiro, Amad. "Measuring the openness of land investment policy related to housing or residential ownership by foreigners in Indonesia." European Research Studies 21.2 (2018): 165-177.
Tanjung, Beatrix, and I. Made Pria Dharsana. "Implications and Validity of the Association of Owners and Residents of Flats Units in Hotel Condominiums." Legal Brief 11.4 (2022): 2185-2200.
Teguh, Pri Pambudi. "Role of The Supreme Court in Legal Dispute Settlement Against Property Certificate Holders with Multiple Certificate Issuance." Wseas Transactions on Business and Economics 20 (2023): 1439-47.
Vatiza, Regina Bunga. "Crossing Regulation Peraturan Pelaksana PPPSRS." Indonesian Notary 3.3 (2021): 29.
Wibisana, Nicholas Ardy, and Retno Dewi Pulung Sari. "Penggunaan Klausula Eksonerasi dalam PPJB Rumah Susun dalam Perspektif Perlindungan Konsumen." Jurnal Hukum Ius Publicum 5.1 (2024): 1-10.
Winarso, Haryo. Residential land developers' behaviour in Jabotabek, Indonesia. Diss. University of London, University College London (United Kingdom), 2000.
Wongso, Sinta, Yuhelson Yuhelson, and Bernard Bernard. "Perlindungan Hukum Bagi Penguni Apartemen Terkait Dengan Dualisme Pembentukan Perhimpunan Penghuni Rumah Susun." Jurnal Multidisiplin Indonesia 2.8 (2023): 2073-2089.
Yuniyanti, Salma Suroyya, and Frency Siska. "Enhancing legal certainty for consumers in apartment unit trade: A comparative analysis of dispute settlement agreements in Indonesia and the Netherlands." Journal of Law and Legal Reform 5.1 (2024): 333-360.
Yuniyanti, Salma Suroyya. "The philosophical foundation of the coherence of regulations concerning apartment in Indonesia." Journal of Morality and Legal Culture 1.1 (2020): 18-23.
Yusuf, Muhiuddin Bahauddin, and Islam H. Elghonaimoy. "Housing dilemma and vertical dimensions." Civil Engineering and Architecture 8.5 (2020): 1107-1118.
Zachman, Nuraini. "Rumah Susun Komersial yang Komprehensif dengan Prinsif Pengelolaan yang Ideal yang Memberikan Perlindungan Hukum Bagi Pemilik Dan Penghuni Satuan Rumah Susun." Legalitas: Jurnal Hukum 12.1 (2020): 137-157.
Zamil, Yusuf Saepul. "Perlindungan Hukum Pembeli Apartemen Atau Rumah Susun Di Atas Tanah Hak Pengelolaan." Arena Hukum 10.3 (2017): 441-461.
Zhu, Jieming, and Hendricus Andy Simarmata. "Formal land rights versus informal land rights: Governance for sustainable urbanization in the Jakarta metropolitan region, Indonesia." Land Use Policy 43 (2015): 63-73.
Downloads
Published
Article ID
31075Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Ruth Elita Gultom, Said Ikramuddin (Author)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
All articles published in the Indonesian Journal of Agrarian Law are made available under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0). By submitting a manuscript to the journal, authors agree to the terms outlined below regarding the distribution, use, and sharing of their work.
